fb

Auditors cleared in landmark negligence case

Auditors cleared in landmark negligence case

This was one of the headlines that recently caught my eye, remembering that auditor’s liability is one of the few ‘new topics’ in ACCA P7.

In August 2009, the UK Law Lords on a split decision (3:2) upheld an earlier ruling by the Court of Appeal in a multi-million pound action brought by the liquidator of Stone & Rolls (a commodity trader) against their auditors Moore Stephens.

The Law Lords ruled that the auditors were not liable for failing to detect a £58 million fraud perpetrated over a number of years.

The fraud involved the CEO of Stone & Rolls, a Croatian businessman called Zvonko Stojevic, using the firm as a means of defrauding banks by means of a letter of credit scam.

The split decision perhaps provides less clarity than the auditing profession might have wished for in relation to the court’s view on an auditor’s liability for the detection of fraud.

The senior Law Lord, Lord Phillips, said “It does not seem just that in these circumstances, Stone & Rolls should be able to bring about a claim that it had set about inducing.”

Lord Manse, dissenting said “the world has sufficient experience of Ponzi schemes ….. for it to be questionable policy to relieve from all responsibility auditors negligently failing in their duty to report on such companies’ activities.”

We could be seeing a whole number of new claims against auditing firms worldwide as companies go into liquidation in the current economic crisis.

What’s your view on this case? Who knows the examiner might ask you!

Share this entry

Recent articles

View All Articles
Out of this world fashion.
Oct 18, 2024
Title
Out of this world fashion.
Excerpt

If you’re lucky enough to buy your clothes from Prada, will your next purchase be a nice dress, […]

Should we park this?
Oct 16, 2024
Title
Should we park this?
Excerpt

Getting the balance right between innovation and ethics is important in business. Frankfurt’s new parking portal offers an […]

Would a good liar make a good accountant?
Oct 12, 2024
Title
Would a good liar make a good accountant?
Excerpt

Do you have children? Have they ever told you a lie? Even a small teeny weeny lie? Well, […]

Was that true? Was that fair?
Oct 09, 2024
Title
Was that true? Was that fair?
Excerpt

I’ve been a qualified accountant for a fair few years now. I had the pleasure of bumping into […]

How much do Big 4 partners get paid?
Oct 03, 2024
Title
How much do Big 4 partners get paid?
Excerpt

Making it to partner at one of the Big 4 accounting firms—Deloitte, EY, KPMG, and PwC—is considered by […]

Problems at Naomi Campbell’s charity…
Oct 02, 2024
Title
Problems at Naomi Campbell’s charity…
Excerpt

The Supermodel Naomi Campbell was recently banned from serving as a charity trustee for five years. This all […]

Lego – building strategy blocks…
Sep 29, 2024
Title
Lego – building strategy blocks…
Excerpt

Many a parent has felt the pain of standing on a Lego brick which their son or daughter […]

Famous accountants, but not for accounting…
Sep 27, 2024
Title
Famous accountants, but not for accounting…
Excerpt

Accounting, often called the “language of business”, has served as a foundational skillset for many who’ve achieved greatness […]