Skip to content

BLACK FRIDAY
Save 20% on ALL Courses

Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
Start Your Next Course
Back to the office but at what cost?

Back to the office but at what cost?

Your employer asks you to spend one more day each week in the office. From management’s perspective, it might sound like a modest change. From yours, it could mean another train fare, different childcare arrangements and several more hours travelling each month.

Both sides may have reasonable arguments. That is what makes Barclays’ latest workplace debate an interesting case for business and accountancy students.

The Financial Times has reported that Barclays, the UK-based international bank, had extended the transition to increased office attendance until the start of 2027 for staff needing more time. Affected employees had been expected to move from at least two office days a week to three from 5 October this year, with senior leaders expected to attend four days. 

The change followed staff opposition. In an open letter, Unite questioned whether a general increase in attendance was justified, while acknowledging the potential benefits of working together in person. It highlighted concerns including travel expenses, commuting time and caring responsibilities. The letter also recorded Barclays’ stated aims of improving collaboration, leadership visibility and decision-making. 

Behind the disagreement sits a question that every manager should be able to answer: what improvement is the organisation trying to achieve?

Consider a trainee accountant working through an unfamiliar problem. Sitting near an experienced colleague could make it easier to ask a quick question, hear how others approach similar issues and learn through observation. A scheduled video meeting may not capture all those informal opportunities.

Now consider an experienced analyst preparing a complex report. A quiet day at home might provide the uninterrupted concentration needed to finish it accurately. Travelling to an office to spend the day on calls with colleagues elsewhere could offer less obvious value.

These are illustrative situations, but they show why the nature of the work matters. The same attendance requirement can have different effects across roles and teams.

Office attendance is easy to count. Its contribution to performance takes more thought.

Entry records might show that employees are present three days a week. They do not establish whether customers receive better service, decisions happen faster or mistakes become less frequent.

A more useful assessment would combine several measures: the quality and timeliness of work, customer outcomes, employee development and staff retention. A team could process more cases while making more errors. Equally, time spent mentoring someone might reduce today’s output while improving their capability for months to come.

For accountancy students, this connects directly to performance measurement. A convenient measure can become a poor target if it draws attention away from the result the organisation actually needs.

There is also a cost-benefit question. Commuting expenses usually fall on employees, so they may never appear in the employer’s accounts. Yet employees’ responses can affect the business. If an attendance change makes recruitment harder or prompts experienced people to leave, replacement costs and disruption could reduce the expected benefits.

That does not mean every employee preference should determine company policy. It means a sound decision needs to consider consequences beyond the most visible costs.

Implementation matters too. If the purpose is better collaboration, teams need opportunities to work together. Bringing people in on different days, without planning shared activities, may achieve little. If the purpose is developing junior staff, experienced colleagues need time available to support them.

Managers also need to explain how exceptions will be handled. Unclear or inconsistent decisions can create resentment, even when individual circumstances justify different arrangements. Consultation can reveal practical difficulties early enough to address them.

One sensible approach would be to establish a baseline, trial the arrangements and review the results. Seasonal workloads, staffing changes and new systems would need consideration before attributing every improvement or decline to location.

The Barclays debate offers a useful management lesson: changing where people work is only valuable if it helps them work better.

The question is easy to put on an attendance spreadsheet: “Were you in the office?”

The harder, more useful question is: “What did being there help us achieve?”

Student using a laptop with coffee on a wooden desk, representing ExP’s free 7-day trial for ACCA, CMA, DipIFR and FIA online courses.

Try our courses free of charge for 7 days

Free 7 day course access

Trusted by the best

Proud to serve leading global companies through our world-class training solutions.

Mead Johnson Nutrition logo on a white background
RBS logo on a white background
Mead Johnson Nutrition logo on a white background
RBS logo on a white background

Invest in yourself today – take the next step with ExP.

Contact us
Cart 0

Your cart is currently empty.

Start Shopping